Mental Health: mind matters

Commercial Motor
December 31, 2018

The mental health of employees is as important in the workplace as their physical wellbeing. It includes an individual’s emotional, psychological and social wellbeing and influences how they handle stress.

Poor mental health can vary from feeling “down” to suffering from anxiety and depression. Usually, an individual’s mental health will fluctuate depending on the pressures they are experiencing.

The UK Department of Health advises that one in four people will at some point experience mental health issues. And almost six in 10 employees (59%) experience workplace stress.

A survey by the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD) revealed stress and mental ill-health were among the most common causes of long-term workplace absence. An employer’s failure to recognise mental health can be costly.

Research shows that mental ill-health costs employers in the UK £30bn each year through lost production, recruitment and absence. Employers should take steps to tackle the causes of workplace stress and actively promote positive mental health among employees.

This can be done in a variety of ways, from raising awareness, training and seminars to proactive wellbeing initiatives such as yoga classes and gym memberships. Promoting a culture of good mental health will help to minimise the risks of employment-related mental ill health and the risk of claims against the employer.

In order to combat workplace stress, employers should:

. carry out a stress audit. This could involve asking employees to list any stress-related concerns; and

. carry out an assessment of the health and safety risks employees are exposed to at work, including an assessment of work-related stress.

To show that they are committed to taking work-related stress seriously employers should implement an anti stress policy. The policy should set out, for example:

. the role and expectations of managers and supervisors to ensure the successful implementation of the policy;

. guidance on resolving cases of stress at work for both the employer and the employee; and

. any internal and external sources of support available for employees who might be suffering from stress, for example, a confidential helpline and/or an occupational health service.

Employers need to ensure the policy is properly implemented in practice by:

. training managers to recognise situations likely to cause stress, to identify symptoms of stress, and how they should manage stress and promote an appropriate culture; and

. conduct return-to-work interviews following a period of sickness absence and performance appraisals. This will help to identify any underlying stress-related work absences or performance issues.

A CIPD survey found that “less than half of respondents report that their organisation supports employees who experience mental-health problems very well or fairly well, while one in five (20%) say that their organisation supports such employees not very well or not at all. Almost three respondents in 10 (28%) don’t know how well their employer supports people who experience mental-health problems”.

Employers need to do more to ensure that employees feel supported with their mental health and should encourage open channels of communication. The arbitration service Acas suggests employers could develop action plans to help promote positive mental health.

This could include:

. the employer’s objectives in relation to mental health and why it is committed to promoting good mental health; arranging training to educate employees and managers to help remove any stigma surrounding mental ill-health;

. putting in place support mechanisms for employees experiencing mental ill-health. For example, having nominated mental health first aiders in the workplace; and
. drafting a mental health policy and reviewing existing policies to ensure employees and managers know where they can obtain support.

Managers should be trained to spot the signs of mental ill-health, including changes in an employee’s usual behaviour, changes in their standard of work, being withdrawn and showing less enthusiasm/interest in tasks and increased sickness absence. Managers should not make assumptions and should regularly ask employees about their wellbeing, and create an open and approachable environment.

Employers should identify areas of the workforce which might be a cause of mental ill-health. For example, employers should hold return-to-work interviews to identify the reason(s) for an employee’s absence.

Employers also need to consider whether or not reasonable adjustments should be provided to employees to support them during periods of mental ill-health. They should consult employees before making any adjustments to establish what support and/or changes they need.

Any adjustments should be documented and regularly reviewed. Although support mechanisms might come at a cost to the employer, in the long term they can help to reduce sickness levels, which will ultimately save on sickness pay, increase workplace productivity, and reduce the possibility of costly claims.

If an employee feels they are suffering from mental ill-health or workplace stress, they should raise this with their line manager, HR manager or somebody else within the workplace. This will give the employer a better understanding of the employee’s position, allowing any necessary adjustments to be made to support those experiencing mental ill-health or workplace stress.

What claims can an employee bring?

. Breach of contract - an employee suffering from work-related stress might argue that their employer has breached an express or implied term of their contract of employment. Additionally, the employee could have a statutory claim for constructive unfair dismissal.
. Unfair dismissal - if an employee is signed off sick from work due to stress or mental health and is subsequently dismissed, they might have a claim for unfair dismissal.

. Disability discrimination - an employee might be protected from disability discrimination if they suffer from mental ill-health issues that have a substantial adverse effect on their ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities. Anxiety and depression could fall within this definition. Whether or not an individual’s work-related stress can be regarded as a disability will be a matter for an employment tribunal to decide.

What are the signs of workplace stress?

Stress is the adverse reaction experienced in response to excessive pressures or demands. Although a certain degree of pressure can help to motivate employees and give them a sense of ambition, which in turn improves job performance and satisfaction, employers should ensure that employees do not become inundated with work.

Stress can affect an employee’s health, reduce their productivity and lead to performance issues. Although stress is not an illness, if it is sustained over a period of time it can lead to, or exacerbate, existing mental-health problems.

By Claire Brook

  • Claire Brook is an employment law partner at Aaron & Partners and can be contacted on 01244 405575 or

About the Author


Commercial Motor is the online presence for Commercial Motor magazine, the world’s oldest magazine dedicated to the commercial vehicle industry.

Share this article

Vehicle Type